32 Comments
User's avatar
Sarah Fleming's avatar

Thank you for your words. For me, my body and it's shape are a source a real and deep distress. I long to be thin again so I don't have to confront that each day. It's good to be shown other ways and that I might one day feel kindness to my body.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

I'm happy that there may be a flicker of hope in there Sarah. Sending love to your distressed parts and wishing that kindness may settle slowly but surely on you and your body 🙏🏻

Expand full comment
Elaine's avatar

I must go and buy new pants. I am at my heaviest and getting dressed each day has become upsetting, and going through the day in uncomfortable clothes is awful. And I hate shopping! But I do believe I'd be happier deciding to be comfortable and having options - not feeling like I deserve to suffer because I haven't lost this weight. Thank you for helping me move towards doing this.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

Here's to new pants! Hurray!

Expand full comment
Kim's avatar

Please be kind to Elaine. You are wise and know if your current weight poses a health risk or is the normal few pounds we seem to pick up as we age. Please opt for comfort, it improves the quality of your life. Warmest regards

Expand full comment
Amy's avatar

I have a cousin who nearly died from anorexia. Her hospitalization and eventual recovery were daily conversational fodder for my grandmother. Every time I went to visit she asked my weight. I was thin due to Celiac but didn't learn that until I was 40.

When I stopped eating gluten it was glorious at first. I went from a US size 2 to 4. Wonderful! I can finally find clothes! Then from a size 4 to 6, then 8. Yay, I have boobs! But I soon discovered this weight gain had no brakes and for the first time had to consider the role of willpower in weight maintenance. Also, I apparently have no willpower.

Today at 63 and size 12 I'm thankful just to be here. Left undiagnosed Celiac would have killed me. We owe our bodies so much gratitude for how hard they work to keep us alive. Still, if anyone has tips on how to lose 10 pounds quickly .... oh never mind.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

Thank you Amy - bodies can be seen as 'wrong' in so many different ways. I'm also thinking of gender and height and colour and..... So glad you were diagnosed. And I'll send you my latest diet sheet... NOT 😉

Expand full comment
Prompt The Prefrontal Cortex's avatar

As a child of the 80s I feel we grew up in a particularly toxic era when it came to the female body. In my teenage years I was massively effected by these messages and the punishment I inflicted on myself lasted decades. Now approaching my 40s and after birthing two children I have a very different view of my body. I am not saying I'm free of insecurity at all times but with initiative eating and regular exercise I'm now the sexiest I've every felt in my life and I'm embracing it.

Expand full comment
Kim's avatar

Sweet Satya, Once again your timing was perfect. At 75 I am not at my heaviest but I have picked up extra weight most of which has landed in my tummy, hips and backside. I kid with friends about being a chubby vegetarian. After my hysterectomy I simply haven’t been able to tolerate tight waist bands so now large shirts and stretchy yoga pants are my main “go to.” I am also on a medication which appears to have added a few lbs after I started using it but I need it so Oh well. As a caregiver I am housebound most days, which means my morning walk and brief activity on a stationary bike aren’t having the impact I’d like. I’ll continue to muddle along with my limited exercise, eat as sensibly as I can and allow myself the occasional treat. I tell myself that at this moment in time - things are what they are. Thank you everyone for writing today. I feel comforted and less alone.

Expand full comment
Jim Melvin's avatar

I've had periods in my life (when I was working out a lot) when I was happy with my body. At 65, my focus has turned more toward health than appearance. As for the photo, I'm glad that you know all this! Many don't. Which is okay. But there's nothing wrong with gentle reminders. And I know the story of the mile porridge well!

Expand full comment
Jim Melvin's avatar

Make that milk porridge. :)

Expand full comment
Kostas Sarantidis's avatar

I’ve always had problems with my body, and I often get angry with it! I’ll try to take your advice and go gently with it, but I make no promises that I will succeed. LOL Thank you.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

Thanks for sharing Kostas - I'm sure you're not the only one who feels this kind of anger. It's not always easy to just 'stop' that kind of thing either - maybe you can head towards being gentle with the angry-at-your-body parts... they're also trying to help! Good luck with your experiment!

Expand full comment
Jim Melvin's avatar

This is going to be a slightly weird comment, so hear me out. First, I thought your post was excellent and the topic speaks to almost all of us, in one way or another. So, well done! Second, this is not a criticism of you at all. I simply wanted to point out that a lot of people mistake the last image you used as being the Buddha, when in reality the Buddha was slim and in great shape. This image is mostly likely Hotei, a Chinese laughing god. Again, you did not misidentify it and did nothing wrong. I just like to pass this along to inform people who might think otherwise. :)

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

Hi Jim, I'm glad you liked the piece - there must be some people who are perfectly happy wiht their bodies, but unfortunately I don't think many... And yes, thanks, I know that the pic is of Hotei - it is a common misunderstanding. I like the story about Shakyamuni Buddha being fed milk porridge by Sujata when he'd almost starved himself to death - maybe he'd approve of the middle way....

Expand full comment
Sharon Martinelli's avatar

A very important conversation. Many of us are on medication that can impact our weight. I have gained almost 70 pounds in 5 years and it’s been very hard on my body. If one more person tells me to just eat less I will scream. I appreciate the link to intuitive eating.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

Thanks for adding that perspective Sharon. So many different causes and conditions when it comes to our weight. And it amazes me that people still think it's their right to make comments like these about other people's bodies, as if we are public property...

Expand full comment
Lizzie Swift's avatar

Very relatable, Satya. My weight has always fluctuated, and I was happiest with my appearance when I dropped to a size 8 in my 40s - stress-induced, in hindsight. And yet, well-intentioned friends would look at me with concern and lament my 'too-thinness'. It was crushing. At 52, I now have a thickened waist, coupled with the pot belly and ample boobs that have always been my default, plus what I condemn as "pudgy" arms. And yet: every so often, from some very sheltered and safe corner inside me, a little voice whispers "Damn, your boobs are magnificent. Wow, look at those sensual curves!" I am so grateful to that little part of me that contains radical, clear-sighted love for this body of mine, and I am so pleased you are finding the joys of your beautiful body too. Thank you for offering a safe space, once again, for us to express ourselves.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

My beautiful body is bowing to your beautiful body _/\_ :)

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

I have been slim most of my life (though I’ve always had a bit of what used to be called a ‘pot belly’ -- I think this was likely due to bad posture).

Anyway, during my (1) pregnancy, I gradually gained 60 lbs. I was amazed. Afterwards, I remember how frustrated I became by the changes in my body. I did get back down to my original weight but things had shifted. My hips were wider for sure, for instance.

Nonetheless, I continued to cram my body into my clothes for a few years. And then: peri-menopause. And then menopause.

The ‘education’ I had received about such things was nil: I had learned a bit about sex and a lot about menstruation, but nothing past that. (My research into fertility, when I was trying to get pregnant, proved fascinating. But it took til my late 30s to learn about that.)

Seems like that’s what it is: you learn as you’re smack-dab already ‘in it’.

I recently decided that cramming myself into my clothes wasn’t fun anymore. I went and bought two pairs of jeans in the next highest size. When I put on the first pair and they glided over my hips and belly, I breathed a sigh of relief. I love when I wear these jeans.

I still try to dress ‘strategically’ (I don’t do form-fitting and I’m always wearing a top that covers the bigger bits) but I’ve come to embrace my body, even while it surprises me every day.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

I know that relief so well :) Thanks for sharing Elle.

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

Your new blue dress = perfection!! 🙌

Expand full comment
Melanie Leavey's avatar

This is beautiful, Satya, thank you for sharing your experience....it's extremely validating.

I'm also at the age (52) where menopausal shifts are changing the way my body looks and I'm partly bemused and partly horrified (but only when I remember to be so, so that should say something!).

I spent my twenties as an exercise rider of racehorses and had a brief stint as a jockey and that experience was very much overshadowed by the need to be a certain weight...ie. 105lbs (preferably less) for an apprentice jockey. I'm naturally on the small side but I struggled with maintaining that weight and food became a deeply unhealthy obsession. I would watch people eating on TV and it would drive me to distraction. Anyway. After that, I swore I would never step on a scale again and I haven't. Of course, that doesn't stop me from noticing my 'menopausal paunch' lol.

I try to remind myself that this is a perfectly natural process...my body needs that extra fat to provide the estrogen that my ovaries are no longer providing...and that this is my 'wisdom belly'. It's a lot of self-talk and self-reassurance and for the most part, it works. But as you say, a lifetime of diet culture and the patriarchal gaze runs deep.

Interestingly - last year we were having some bathroom renovations done and, as such, there was no mirror in the bathroom for several months. I've never felt happier with how I look. ;)

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

I didn’t know about the extra fat (via menopause) being needed for the estrogen... WHY DIDN’T I KNOW THIS??!!

I’m writing in all caps becuz I’m mad. I’m mad becuz I’m 56 years old and I’m STILL discovering things about my body that I didn’t know.

I’m not sure what the solution to that is. Why did Health class teach me about STDs and drugs, for instance, but not about my body?

Expand full comment
Melanie Leavey's avatar

right?!?! There's such a lack of information about our own bodies out there, it's ridiculous. And the info that is out there is mostly about HRT and trying to pretend it's not happening. (nothing wrong with HRT if that's what's right for you! It's just not an option for everyone.) Anyway - I turned to Susun Weed's book "New Menopausal Years - The Wise Woman Way" on the recommendation of an older friend...which has helped me reframe a lot of what's happening.

"Fat cells convert androstenedione, a substance produced by the adrenals and the ovaries into estrone, the primary postmenopausal estrogen. Women who gain weight during menopause have less severe hot flashes, an easier change and denser bones." <3

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

I did for sure have an ‘easier change’, for what it’s worth.

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

Yes!

I’m going to get both the book you suggested and the one Satya did—and then I feel like, I don’t know, buying them for younger friends!

(I know when I was learning about fertility. I kept thinking ‘I need to tell people about this!’, like it was some kind of esoteric knowledge, lol. But seriously, I grew up thinking a girl could get pregnant any time she has intercourse: surprise! Nope!)

Expand full comment
Melanie Leavey's avatar

I'm chuckling over the idea of it being some kind of esoteric knowledge...because that's exactly what it feels like! So here we are, quietly passing books back and forth....lol I think the difficulty many women have with talking about menopause - and then so don't - is because it's obviously age related and therefore not an 'attractive' subject.

Expand full comment
Satya Robyn's avatar

That last quote makes me happy Melanie! (and thanks for sharing everything you've shared). I read 'Wise Power' (Alexander Pope) on the menopause and it did a similar job of reframing but psychologically - the potential gains in taking stock of our lives, getting better at saying no etc - seems we have to share these resources between ourselves as no-one else is talking about it...

Expand full comment
Melanie Leavey's avatar

Exactly! i liked Susun Weed's approach for the same reason..it's about deciding what we wish to take with us into the next stage of our lives. I've found that extremely helpful..to focus on the gains, rather than the losses.

Expand full comment
Melanie Leavey's avatar

One last thought....one of my favourite re-frames is from 'hot flash' to 'power surge'. :D

Expand full comment
Elle J's avatar

Yes!

Expand full comment